A customer once brought us a rusted Cadillac Escalade. He loved that truck, he had a real attachment to it, and he wanted every single repair done. My team inspected it and wrote up the full estimate, and it came to somewhere around $8,000 to $9,000. It was a big estimate.
I looked at the car and told him, "we are not working on this car."
The frame was really falling out of the car. Even after $8,000 or $9,000 of repairs, it would still be a rusty truck with a failing frame underneath it. I just can't honestly take somebody's $8,000 or $9,000 for that. When I turn work down, I have to be very honest with the customer and inform them exactly why.
There is no magic number
People ask me whether there is a rule, like four broken things means fix it and ten broken things means walk away. My answer is that it depends.
Here in New England we see a lot of rusty vehicles, so rust comes up all the time. When the rust is in the frame, like it was on that Escalade, fixing everything else still leaves you with a rusty car. The question I ask is whether the car is still worth investing in.
Think about replacement value
When a customer is deciding whether to fix a car, I tell them to think about the replacement value of that car.
Say you have a car that has been in your family for ten years and it is paid off. We can fix it for about $5,000, and you can drive it for another three years. Now think about what it actually costs to replace it:
A down payment
Sales tax and excise tax
Registration fees
The depreciation that hits a new car the moment you drive it off the lot
A monthly payment, often on a loan stretched past 72 months
A loan that long can run close to the useful life of the car itself. It starts to look a lot like a mortgage. Put all of that next to a $5,000 repair on a car you already own, and for a lot of families the repair makes sense.
What three old RAV4s taught me
Near my parents' house there is a wealthy neighborhood, and one day I was walking through it and saw three RAV4s in one driveway. They were 15 to 20 years old, and all three were clean and well maintained.
To me that is a great customer. When someone keeps an older car that clean, it tells you they care about it. It's their baby.
My mother has an alterations business [VERIFY: current or past] in Western Massachusetts, and she saw the same thing with clothing. Her wealthy clients brought their clothes in to be repaired and kept wearing them. It reminds me of Rich Dad Poor Dad: spend your money on things that make your life better, and leave the neighbors out of it.
The customer makes the decision
None of this means I decide for the customer. They make the decision, but I make sure I give them a lot of information to make an educated decision.
Some people have called me a salesperson for the way we present work. It is my job to present this to the customer. The car will tell me what it needs, and I sell what the car needs.
We are looking for long-term customers, the people who come back to us year after year.
If you are trying to decide whether your car is worth fixing, bring it to Pleasant Car Care in Newton or Watertown and we will look it over and tell you honestly what we see.